Players › Compare
Compare two players
Put two players who do the same job side by side. For each stat you see where both rank in the league, and whether the gap between them is bigger than the noise a few plays create.
Grades updated Rechecked every few hours on game days
San Francisco 49ers · OL
On the stats that count, Dominick Puni and Colton McKivitz are too close to separate with the plays we have. 5 are too close to call.
The year so far: Line run success
Where each has ranked among offensive linemen after every week. Solid line is Dominick Puni, dashed is Colton McKivitz.
Stat by stat
Sacks allowed by his line (lower is better)
Too close to callA 2.0%1st of 166
9.1%worse to better3.5%B 2.0%1st of 166
Line run success
Too close to callA 47%23rd of 162
33%worse to better48%B 47%23rd of 162
Penalties per 1,000 snaps (lower is better)
Too close to callA 3.456th of 152
13.0worse to better0.0B 3.453rd of 152
Holding per 1,000 snaps (lower is better)
Too close to callA 3.4109th of 152
6.4worse to better0.0B 0.040th of 152
False starts per 1,000 snaps (lower is better)
Too close to callA 0.044th of 152
6.6worse to better0.0B 3.4104th of 152
Style
- Share of snaps when he playsDominick Puni: 98% · Colton McKivitz: 100%
“Clearly ahead” means the gap is bigger than what the plays behind each number could produce by chance. “Slightly” means it points one way but could still be noise.
The money
Contract and cap numbers side by side. Bars share one scale, so the longer bar is the bigger number. A bigger number is not a better one: it is only what each is paid.
Average per year
Dominick PuniA$1.4MColton McKivitzB$15.0MWhat the contract pays on average each year.
Cap hit this season
Dominick PuniA$1.6MColton McKivitzB$5.8MWhat he counts against his team's cap in 2026. It can be far from the average year on a deal that is backloaded.
Share of the cap
Dominick PuniA0.5%Colton McKivitzB1.9%This season's cap hit as a share of the league cap.
Total value
Dominick PuniA$5.7MColton McKivitzB$45.0MGuaranteed money
Dominick PuniA$966KColton McKivitzB$18.7MFully guaranteed at signing, as OverTheCap reports it.
Pay rank at his job
Dominick PuniA143 of 161Colton McKivitzB43 of 161Among the players at that job we hold a contract for, 1 is the highest paid.
- Among the 161 offensive linemen we have a grade and a contract for, Dominick Puni is 3rd on the field and 143rd in pay. His grade is still an early read, so this says nothing yet about whether his pay is fair.
- Among the 161 offensive linemen we have a grade and a contract for, Colton McKivitz is 2nd on the field and 43rd in pay. His grade is still an early read, so this says nothing yet about whether his pay is fair.
Contract figures as of 2026-10-12, read from public cap pages for all 32 teams. A player with no row there, such as a practice-squad name, shows “not tracked”. See pay against play for every position.
Data: nflverse play-by-play, CC BY 4.0. Also FTN charting, Pro Football Reference advanced stats, snap counts and injury reports, all through nflverse. Calculations and charts by Raiders Rundown.
More from the Lab
All 9 tools →- NFL Playoff MachineNewThrough week 5Pick every game left and watch the seeds, bracket and playoff odds move.
- Sunday Rooting GuideNewThrough week 5Which games to root for, ranked by how much each moves your team's playoff odds.
- This week's matchupsWeek 5Every game on the slate, position group by position group.
- Top playsThe snaps that moved the Raiders' chance to win the most.
- Scouting reportsWeek 5Where the Raiders have the edge on every opponent.
- How all 32 teams stack upQuarterback, line, receivers and coverage, ranked across the league.
- Will it last?The Raiders' hottest and coldest stats, against teams since 1999.
- Season twinsThe past teams that looked the most like these Raiders.