Players › Compare

Compare two players

Put two players who do the same job side by side. For each stat you see where both rank in the league, and whether the gap between them is bigger than the noise a few plays create.

Grades updated Mon, Oct 12, 3:02 AM ETRechecked every few hours on game days

A Green Bay Packers · K

Trey Smack

36overall grade, well below average

30th of 31 kickers

B Tennessee Titans · K

Joey Slye

42overall grade, below average

26th of 31 kickers

On the stats that count, Trey Smack and Joey Slye are too close to separate with the plays we have. 3 are too close to call.

The year so far: Field goals over expected

Where each has ranked among kickers after every week. Solid line is Trey Smack, dashed is Joey Slye.

Stat by stat

Field goals over expected
Too close to call
A −14.7 pts26th of 31
−15.3 ptsworse to better+14.1 pts
B −4.9 pts19th of 31
Field goal percentage
Too close to call
A 70%30th of 31
71%worse to better100%
B 83%13th of 31
EPA per kickoff
Too close to call
A −0.6032nd of 33
−0.52worse to better+0.01
B −0.5331st of 33

Style

Average try distanceTrey Smack: 41.8 yds · Joey Slye: 39.0 yds
Tries from 50+Trey Smack: 20% · Joey Slye: 17%
Kickoff touchbacksTrey Smack: 15% · Joey Slye: 50%

“Clearly ahead” means the gap is bigger than what the plays behind each number could produce by chance. “Slightly” means it points one way but could still be noise.

← All players

Data: nflverse play-by-play, CC BY 4.0. Also FTN charting, Pro Football Reference advanced stats, snap counts and injury reports, all through nflverse. Calculations and charts by Raiders Rundown.

More from the Lab

All 9 tools →